Pros and Cons of Paleo Diet – Why You Might Be Struggling

If you’ve ever tried the paleo diet to solve stubborn weight gain, brain fog, or instability in blood sugar, you’re not alone. Nearly 80% of weight-loss gains on special diets are regained within 5 years; a reality for many dieters in Canada and the U.S. Without clear guidance, you may adopt changes only to fall back and feel worse.

This reflects how the clean-label movement is driving the popularity of paleo.

In this blog, we’ll break down the pros and cons of the paleo diet so you can make an informed decision about whether this ancient approach fits your modern lifestyle.

Understanding Paleo Diet Benefits: What it Really Offers

You eat only whole, unprocessed foods—meats, fish, nuts, fruits, vegetables—eliminating grains, legumes, dairy, and refined sugar. That shift alone often boosts nutrient density. 

One trial found that paleo eaters consumed 32% more fiber and 28% more potassium than those following standard nutrition guidelines.

The Pros of the Paleo Diet for Everyday Health

When you switch to a clean meat, vegetable, and fruit diet, you often feel more satiated, see improvements in blood pressure and cholesterol, and may experience reduced inflammation. 

For example, one study showed that C-reactive protein (CRP) levels dropped by 0.51 mg/L, alongside improved lipid profiles and reduced liver fat compared to low-fat dieting.

Weighing the Paleo Diet Pros and Cons for Athletic or Metabolic Goals

If you’re active, the pros of the paleo diet include high‑quality protein for recovery. But the con is often insufficient carbs, which can hinder endurance. 

Some metabolic studies have shown improvements, but the results are inconsistent compared to Mediterranean or diabetes diets.

Go Full Paleo Consistently and See the Gains You Want!

Order paleo meal delivery for delicious prepared meals.

Learn More

Common Cons of Paleo Diet: Practical Challenges You Face

Strict removal of dairy, grains, and legumes can result in deficiencies in calcium, iodine, B vitamins, and fiber. Medical sources warn that excluding these groups may harm bone health and thyroid function. Paleo’s intensity can also make social meals and travel difficult.

Disadvantages of the Paleo Diet for Long‑Term Nutritional Balance

Follow it long enough, and deficiencies emerge: studies show calcium intake on paleo may be only one‑third of daily needs (≈ 355–395 mg vs recommended ~1000 mg). Without food group diversity, micronutrient gaps can accumulate, risking osteoporosis, fatigue, thyroid imbalance, or cognitive changes.

Quick Overview: Pros and Cons of the Paleo Diet

Paleo Diet Disadvantages in Real‑World Sustainability

This way of eating is time‑intensive: lots of meal prep, careful sourcing, no grab‑and‑go. That leads many to drop out—only 35% of people stuck with the paleo diet over a year in a clinical trial, versus 57% for the Mediterranean diet. The cost of organic produce and grass‑fed meat is also significantly higher, making sustained adoption difficult.

Advantages of the Paleo Diet Over More Processed Diets

Despite its limitations, the paleo diet has several advantages, including the dramatic reduction of processed additives, refined sugars, and simple starches. 

You're emphasizing whole ingredients with zero preservatives, which aligns with cleaner eating trends and may support long‑term metabolic resilience.

Summing It Up: Paleo Diet Advantages and Limitations

To recap: the pros of the paleo diet include better satiety, possible reductions in inflammation, improved lipid markers, and cleaner eating.